Old Billings federal courthouse hits auction block

2013-02-06T09:37:00Z 2013-05-09T16:19:08Z Old Billings federal courthouse hits auction blockBy CLAIR JOHNSON cjohnson@billingsgazette.com The Billings Gazette

The asbestos-contaminated former James F. Battin Federal Courthouse went on the online auction block Wednesday, and within hours the downtown building got some nibbles.

William A. Morgan, a project manager for the federal General Services Administration in Fort Worth, Texas, said the agency already had received expressions of interest in the property.

The minimum bid is $1. A bidder has to provide a $45,000 refundable deposit for what the GSA has declared surplus property.

Completed in 1965, the five-story box measures 221,000 square feet on nearly an acre at 316 N. 26th St. The property also has a 56-car underground parking garage.

GSA’s listing calls the sale “a unique opportunity to acquire a significant building located in the Central Business District of Billings.”

A fact sheet on the building at GSA’s website provides notice about the asbestos, with more details to be included as part of sale information.

Asbestos contamination ultimately led to the construction of a new $80 million federal courthouse that opened last fall a block away. Another $30 million federal office building is under construction to house the remaining federal employees still working in the old courthouse.

When state and local government agencies and homeless assistance agencies all passed last year on acquiring the building, GSA decided to sell it as surplus property. Last spring, GSA said it would be conveying the property “as is, where is.”

While two Billings developers said they didn’t know how much asbestos removal would cost or what the property is worth, they saw potential for the property and hoped it would end up in the hands of locals.

Marty Connell, president of the East Billings Urban Renewal District and restorer and developer of the former Pierce Packing plant into the Kairos Center, envisions “Class A rental space” for the building.

“I would love to see local people coming together” to buy the property, remove the asbestos, upgrade and modernize the space, Connell said.

“It’s a nice building in a great part of town. I think it’s too much of gem for the city to say we’re going to let it be in someone else’s hands. That’s my controlling-freak approach to it,” he said.

Connell’s original dream of the city and county acquiring the property and converting it into a central location for local government services was “shot down,” he said. “They decided it didn’t fit them.”

Connell said Billings doesn’t have a lot of Class A office space available and it would take time for the market to absorb that much space. But done right, the building will attract people, he said.

“I have a problem with being too optimistic. We may be able to attract a company like Halliburton,” Connell said. Another possibility may be federal or state agencies looking to consolidate offices, he said.

“You got to think in the future of Billings, Montana,” Connell said.

Mike Schaer, of Computers Unlimited, who has spent more than 30 years transforming Montana Avenue into a popular area with restaurants and art galleries, thinks the asbestos issue will result in the GSA practically giving away the property.

Tearing the building down would probably be easier than trying to work on it, Schaer said.

But if someone removes the asbestos, Schaer suggested apartment housing for the building’s second life.

“That would be fantastic. I think the best use would be apartments. The next-best use would be a parking lot. I think there’s plenty of commercial space available downtown now,” he said.

“If it were closer to Montana Avenue, I would be more interested,” Schaer said.

GSA has not yet set an end date for the bidding.

Sally Mayberry, GSA spokeswoman in Denver, said the agency typically has a “soft close” or “inactivity period” beginning in the last 24-hour period before a preset sale closing date.

GSA will announce when the auction is closing when “sufficient marketing efforts have been met” and potential bidders have had a chance to inspect the property, Mayberry said. The notice will be posted on GSA’s sale website two to three weeks before closing. The sale will end after the inactivity period has passed without any bids being placed.

That inactivity period could be less than 24 hours and GSA encourages bidders to pay close attention to the countdown clock on at www.realestatesales.gov.

Mayberry said GSA does not share what it considers to be the fair market value of the building but encourages bidders to do their own research on value.

In setting the minimum bid at $1, the online auction is similar to a live auction and an auctioneer setting starting bids to encourage buyers, Mayberry said.

If no one bids, will GSA demolish the building or try another sale?

GSA has “a high success rate at conveying property” and will use its expertise to make sure the sale of the old Battin courthouse also is a success, Mayberry said.

The public can find more information about the auction by contacting Morgan at 817-978-4239 or william.morgan@gsa.gov or by visiting RealEstateSales.gov or PropertyDisposal.gsa.gov.

Copyright 2015 The Billings Gazette. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

(12) Comments

  1. BillingsCapitolofNewOldWest
    Report Abuse
    BillingsCapitolofNewOldWest - April 23, 2013 2:40 pm
    We will see
  2. tnm music
    Report Abuse
    tnm music - February 09, 2013 12:02 am
    here a idea. condo's, imax theater, tgi friday, mall, office space,and parking garage. HOUSTON I THINK WE HAVE LIFT OFF.
  3. tnm music
    Report Abuse
    tnm music - February 08, 2013 11:54 pm
    I am being realistic. You people have to get around the country more. This is what their doing in Spokane,Bosie,Colorordo Springs, Fargo, Provo, and other mid sized cities.
  4. MTGirl01
    Report Abuse
    MTGirl01 - February 07, 2013 9:13 am
    This is Billings, a small town, that building would be empty. Let's be realistic.
  5. Billings-center-of-Montana-Wyoming
    Report Abuse
    Billings-center-of-Montana-Wyoming - February 07, 2013 5:59 am
    Floor tiles no realistic problem it's the asmbestos on air handling and asbestos sprayed on structural beams for fire protection that's a problem

    Tear it down and rebuild tall and proud with parking and landscaping

  6. Jason Smith
    Report Abuse
    Jason Smith - February 07, 2013 4:11 am
    School district 2 sent out letters stating the Billings schools are contaminated with asbestos, poisoning our children but there is nothing they can do. Tiles contaminated, coming loose, exposing children to poison, so much for Safe Kid's-Safe Communities. Leaving a contaminated building vacant , possibly it could be Billings next school. Rimrock Elementary has been empty for years, refuse to sell or use, yet Billings is considering building a new school? Looks like we have our answers.
  7. fidlr
    Report Abuse
    fidlr - February 07, 2013 4:01 am
    A possibility could be a construction company which specializes in asbestos removal buying it for a bargain basement price. Their cost of asbestos removal would be minimal to them. Then they could resell it to a developer to remodel in any fashion that would be profitable. It seems a shame to simply tear it down. We should remember that demolishing it would still involve a great deal of asbestos hazard to those nearby. It is very close to buildings with many people working there.
  8. Billings-center-of-Montana-Wyoming
    Report Abuse
    Billings-center-of-Montana-Wyoming - February 06, 2013 8:50 pm
    Tear it down its cheaper than 20 million clean up and thirty million remodel without parking. Bad stp backwards

    A tall thirty story multiuser international design with offices, apart,nets, condos, cinema parking, air tram connection to the airport is the answer

  9. tnm music
    Report Abuse
    tnm music - February 06, 2013 7:03 pm
    Tear it down, and and build a 30 to 35 story high-rise multi-purpose building starting the next boom downtown. It's time billings gets ready for the next 100 years. Not the last. We made so in roads on the west end, downtown is next. This is it.
  10. MTGirl01
    Report Abuse
    MTGirl01 - February 06, 2013 3:29 pm
    Make it a prison, put life sentence criminals in there, who cares if they get asbestos poisoning.
  11. End Daze
    Report Abuse
    End Daze - February 06, 2013 1:59 pm
    This is the federal government shirking its responsibilities. This is the federal government doing exactly what it promised the community it would not do. This is the federal government creating a long term problem for Billings. The federal government should be paying someone $16 million to take the builiding off their hands. This is the federal government we are supposed to trust to look out for our futures, livelihoods and health care. Oh yeah, warms the cockles of your heart don't they?
  12. Billings-center-of-Montana-Wyoming
    Report Abuse
    Billings-center-of-Montana-Wyoming - February 06, 2013 12:12 pm
    asbestos removal $16 MIllion in 2003, todays cost?????
    if ya buy it and remove asbestos then can this albatross be saved or usable? probably not?

    feds should have to tear it down asbeswtos and all and sell to a national or international developer! high rise multi use like in Boise,,,,

    Please no more modern ugly boxes downtown....

Comment policy

We provide this forum for readers to exchange ideas and opinions on the day's news. Passionate views, pointed criticism and critical thinking are welcome. Name-calling, crude language and abuse are not. You must be logged into a personal account on Facebook to comment (FAQ). Readers are responsible for their comments and abuse of this privilege will not be tolerated. We reserve the right, without warning or notification, to remove comments and block users we determine violate our Terms of Service. Comments reflect the opinions of the author - not those of The Billings Gazette or its parent company.

Add Comment
You must Login to comment.

Click here to get an account it's free and quick

More from the Gazette

3 hurt in car vs. semi wreck south of Broadview

3 hurt in car vs. semi wreck south of Broadview

5 hours ago Photos




11 hours ago(0)

Clouds and showers to cap Memorial Day weekend

May 24, 2015 11:59 am(0)
Review Melissa Rivers lauds and laughs in 'The Book of Joan'

Review Melissa Rivers lauds and laughs in 'The Book of Joan'

May 24, 2015 10:00 am(0)
Pair of armed men rob casino Friday night

Pair of armed men rob casino Friday night

May 23, 2015 8:16 am(0)
Vandals strike Lockwood’s Hillner Park

Vandals strike Lockwood’s Hillner Park

May 23, 2015 8:00 am Photos


Trampoline park coming to Billings' West End

Trampoline park coming to Billings' West End

May 22, 2015 8:30 pm Photos


Man pleads guilty to stabbing outside South Side bar

Man pleads guilty to stabbing outside South Side bar

May 22, 2015 8:15 pm(0)

Follow The Billings Gazette

Popular Stories

Get weekly ads via e-mail

Deals & Offers

Featured Businesses