Nat Hentoff: Suleiman's long torture partnership with the CIA

2011-02-10T00:00:00Z Nat Hentoff: Suleiman's long torture partnership with the CIABy NAT HENTOFF The Billings Gazette
February 10, 2011 12:00 am  • 

As the inflamed mass movements to topple Hosni Mubarak crested, top Obama officials pushed the autocratic ruler to hand over his authority, with the support of the Egyptian military — to Omar Suleiman, long Mubarak's closest aide, former head of intelligence and recently elevated by him to the vice presidency. Despite the enormous coverage of this rebellion, how many Americans know of Mr. Suleiman's extensive partnership with our CIA's renditions? Of terrorism suspects to be tortured in Egypt? Many eventually disappeared.

An especially revealing introduction to Mubarak's chief torturer is Jane Mayer's “Who is Omar Suleiman” (, Jan. 29). For years, this author of “The Dark Side” (Dick Cheney's scenario for our extrajudicial war on terror) has been a leading fact-based investigator of the Bush-Cheney torture policy as well as such other Obama suspensions of the Constitution as his drone planes' targeted killings of suspects who have never been brought before a judge. At least one American is on that list.

CIA renditions

“Suleiman,” she writes “was not squeamish.” Each rendition was authorized at the very top levels of both governments. These classified kidnappings began during the Clinton administration.

And, as Stephen Grey reports in “Ghost Plane,” Suleiman, long well-known in Washington, “understood English well, was an urbane and sophisticated man.”

One particularly brutal torture session led to then Secretary of State Colin Powell's most acutely embarrassing international experience: The prisoner, Ibn Sheikh al-Libi, was captured by Pakistan and then rushed by the CIA to Egypt, where intelligence chief Suleiman was in charge of his torture.

As Mayer writes: “They locked him in a cage for 80 hours. Then they took him out, knocked him over, and punched him” and so thoroughly abused him that he gave up and lied that the Iraqis had weapons of mass destruction, thereby “documenting” the justification for the United States going to war against Iraq.

Given this false information by the CIA, Secretary of State Powell confidently repeated it in his pivotal address to the United Nations in February 2003. So it could be said that torturer Suleiman was a key factor in precipitating our invasion of Iraq.

After it appeared evident that there had been no weapons of mass destruction in Iraq, and Saddam Hussein had been fatally retired, al-Libi admitted that he had indeed lied. As Mayer reports: “When the FBI later asked him why he lied, he blamed the brutality of the Egyptian intelligence service.”

Moreover, in Michael Isikoff and David Corn's book, “Hubris,” al-Libi added to his explanation of why he had lied: “They were killing me. I had to tell them something.”

Entrenched torturers

As I write this, President Obama has again personally urged President Mubarak to leave office to allow the start of democracy in Egypt. These remarks by Obama, reports the Feb. 5 Daily News, “came amid reports that U.S. officials floated a plan to turn over power now — not in September — to a transitional government headed by Vice President Omar Suleiman.”

Torture may still be deeply entrenched in the Mubarak-Suleiman regime, as it may still be in Obama's with CIA Director Leon Panetta continuing renditions. The American public is still not being told who is being rendered and why.

The Egyptians have been surging in the streets for their own liberation from dictator Mubarak and his key enforcers such as Suleiman. They have also shaken other Mideast dictators. If real-life democracy does become rooted in Egypt, at some point will torturer Suleiman be brought to trial? If he is, can that lead to some of our American torturers, all the way up the chain of command, being brought before at least an independent due-process commission equipped with subpoena power?

Or is that asking too much of this constitutional republic?

Copyright 2015 The Billings Gazette. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

More from the Gazette

Nat Hentoff: High court should open up to cameras

January 04, 2012 12:00 amLoading…

Sebelius should apologize to insurance firms

September 24, 2010 12:05 amLoading…

Nat Hentoff: Court asked to decide: Was Rumsfeld a torturer?

March 26, 2010 12:00 amLoading…

Nat Hentoff: Citizens still excluded from U.S. Supreme Court

March 19, 2010 12:00 amLoading…

Nat Hentoff: Liz Cheney, Bill Kristol resurrect McCarthy with ‘Al Qaida Seven’ ad

March 11, 2010 12:00 amLoading…

Does robotic war make killing too easy?

November 25, 2009 12:00 amLoading…

Nat Hentoff: What is the CIA still hiding about interrogations?

September 04, 2009 12:00 amLoading…

Nat Hentoff: Another case of police handcuffing nonviolent speech

August 06, 2009 12:00 amLoading…

Follow The Billings Gazette

Popular Stories

Get weekly ads via e-mail

Deals & Offers

Featured Businesses