Judge grants new trial in MPC worker's comp case because of juror misconduct

2012-05-18T08:28:00Z 2012-05-19T18:54:05Z Judge grants new trial in MPC worker's comp case because of juror misconductBy JOHN GRAN EMEIGH Montana Standard The Billings Gazette

BUTTE — One juror’s misconduct has caused the verdict in a nearly month-long trial against the former Montana Power Co. to be thrown out and a new trial granted.

Butte District Judge Kurt Krueger ruled that a juror “tipped the scale of justice” during deliberations in the trial. The trial stemmed from a worker’s compensation lawsuit filed by former Montana Power employees against the now-defunct utility.

In Tuesday’s ruling, the judge granted a new trial for the 141 former employees because a juror presented outside information to his fellow jurors.

The judge’s decision dismisses February’s 8-4 jury verdict in favor of Montana Power, which saved the former utility from paying potentially millions of dollars in damages. The judge determined that juror Brian Vieke brought “prejudicial information” to the other 11 jurors’ attention during the two days of deliberations. Vieke reviewed and told the other jurors about his employee manual that wasn’t presented as evidence, according to the ruling.

He also shared personal information about one of the plaintiffs, contending the employee had a history of filing worker’s compensation claims, the ruling stated.

Even though Vieke claims to have known the plaintiff for a long time, he didn’t share this information during jury selection.

Krueger stated in his ruling that the jury was reminded each day of the trial not to discuss the case with anyone or consider any evidence not presented during the trial.

Missoula attorney Lon Dale, who represented the former employees, asked the court for a new trial in April after learning from other jurors about Vieke’s actions.

Montana Power attorney Joe Seifert argued during the motion hearing in April that a new trial wasn’t necessary because the other jurors claimed that their decisions weren’t influence by Vieke’s comments.

Attempts to contact Vieke for comment were unsuccessful.

The employees’ lawsuit claimed the now-defunct utility neglected to attempt to pay its workers’ compensation benefits when liability was reasonably clear going back to 1977.

Attorneys for both parties didn’t return phone messages seeking comment.

Though Tuesday’s ruling says Vieke is accused of jury misconduct, it doesn’t state if he faces legal consequences.

Chief Deputy County Attorney Samm Cox said on Thursday that no charge has been filed against Vieke.

Copyright 2015 The Billings Gazette. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

(2) Comments

  1. Ghost man 549
    Report Abuse
    Ghost man 549 - May 18, 2012 4:57 pm
    Fat Albert sang a song once. Dope is for Dopes. Bill Cosby, a smart man or what.
  2. cme
    Report Abuse
    cme - May 18, 2012 12:16 pm
    that is what is wrong with the justice system. many times there is information withheld from the jury that would make a difference in the verdict. all information should be allowed, if it can be verified to be true.

Comment policy

We provide this forum for readers to exchange ideas and opinions on the day's news. Passionate views, pointed criticism and critical thinking are welcome. Name-calling, crude language and abuse are not. You must be logged into a personal account on Facebook to comment (FAQ). Readers are responsible for their comments and abuse of this privilege will not be tolerated. We reserve the right, without warning or notification, to remove comments and block users we determine violate our Terms of Service. Comments reflect the opinions of the author - not those of The Billings Gazette or its parent company.

Add Comment
You must Login to comment.

Click here to get an account it's free and quick

More from the Gazette

Park City worker admits money order scam

10 hours ago(0)
Montana high school seniors build custom fly rods for charity

Montana high school seniors build custom fly rods for charity

13 hours ago(0)

Follow The Billings Gazette

Popular Stories

Get weekly ads via e-mail

Featured Businesses