$500K bail removed as St. Ignatius boy's evaluation begins

2013-05-11T08:37:00Z 2013-06-06T15:31:10Z $500K bail removed as St. Ignatius boy's evaluation beginsBy VINCE DEVLIN Missoulian The Billings Gazette
May 11, 2013 8:37 am  • 

ST. IGNATIUS — An unusually high $500,000 bail holding a 10-year-old boy in custody for the past week was removed Thursday after a neuropsychological evaluation on the child began, but his family vowed Friday to continue their fight to bring Isaiah Shane Nasewytewa home.

District Court Judge Kim Christopher released Nasewytewa from a juvenile detention center on his own recognizance, but with the stipulation he enter a residential treatment center in Butte.

His grandmother and legal guardian, Dorinda Buck, of St. Ignatius, said the move was like taking her grandson "from the pot into the fire. I object to any kind of mental facility."

The boy, whose recent conduct at school got him re-charged with felony burglary, criminal mischief and criminal trespass from a 2012 incident, had been held at the Reintegrating Youthful Offenders Correctional Facility in Galen.

He's now at Acadia Montana in Butte, which describes itself as a residential treatment center for young people ages 8 to 18, in need of assistance with co-occurring behavioral, emotional and psychiatric disorders.

"It's basically a mental hospital," Buck said Friday, after a rally at her home in St. Ignatius. "I said, 'Why, why?' "

***

At a Wednesday hearing in Polson, it was revealed that the boy had already missed three previously scheduled neuropsychological evaluations while in the care of various family members.

His parents have separated, and Buck testified that Nasewytewa's mother moved to Arizona last fall. Nasewytewa was later removed from his father's care by Confederated Salish and Kootenai Tribal Child Protective Services, for reasons that weren't disclosed in court, and placed in his grandmother's care.

The boy, testimony showed, had also missed nine of 15 scheduled weekly sessions with mental-health professionals in St. Ignatius since being placed with his grandmother in January.

Christopher indicated she had set bail at $500,000 -- 10 times more than the county attorney's office requested, and 50 times higher than what Nasewytewa's public defender sought - to ensure the neuropsychological evaluation finally took place.

The boy's attorney, Steve Eschenbacher, argued the criminal justice system was being misused to deliver mental-health services. He called Buck to the stand to testify she was willing to be appointed an officer of the court, charged with getting her grandson to the evaluation in Bozeman on Thursday and again on May 17 - and under threat of jail time for herself if the appointments weren't kept -- if the judge reduced bail so the child could return home.

On cross-examination, the previously missed evaluations and mental-health appointments for the child were brought to light.

Deputy Lake County Attorney Cory Allen also questioned Buck about multiple reports from the boy's elementary school, where he was accused of unprovoked attacks on other students. Allen asked about three of the alleged incidents, then noted he was only on page two of 27 pages worth of reports from the school involving Nasewytewa's behavior.

While unable to recall details of specific calls she received from school administrators, Buck said her grandson had posed no discipline problems in her home, and testified that he played after school with some of the same children he was accused of attacking in school.

***

Buck said she was on the phone with her attorney, Matt O'Neill, of Polson, Thursday when O'Neill was notified another court proceeding in Nasewytewa's case had just been scheduled.

"I couldn't even get there, it happened so fast," Buck said.

She and O'Neill had been working on a proposal to have Nasewytewa placed in foster care in the Mission Valley, pending the completion of his neuropsychological evaluation, Buck said.

The grandmother said she still prefers that to Nasewytewa being treated in Butte. The family turned to social and traditional media to protest the $500,000 bail set for a 10-year-old, an amount they said is usually reserved for adults accused of the most violent of crimes.

An aunt who previously had taken in Nasewytewa after his parents' separation drove through the night from her home in Olympia, Wash., to speak at Friday morning's rally.

Valerie Bourdon's message, Buck said, was "that we're not going to give up."

At the judge's request, family members were allowed to say goodbye to Nasewytewa after Wednesday's hearing. Each was given about 30 seconds with the boy, who was in another room, Buck said, one at a time.

"He was in shackles and handcuffs," Buck said through tears. "He's not a hardened criminal of any kind. He's just a 10-year-old kid. It was very hard for a grandmother to see."

The 2012 burglary of a Polson rafting company, which Nasewytewa was charged with at the age of 9, involved another minor. According to Wednesday's hearing, the other minor allegedly broke a window and had the smaller Nasewytewa climb inside.

Nasewytewa was covered in cuts from the broken glass when questioned by law enforcement, it was stated.

The case was settled through a deferred prosecution agreement wherein the charges eventually would have been dropped if the boy met certain conditions.

When he was cited for disorderly conduct after allegedly throwing a metal desk, yelling at an administrator and banging his head on a window at school, those terms had been violated, and the charges from the burglary were re-filed.

Dr. Robert Velin, of Bozeman, is conducting the neuropsychological evaluation. His report, after the evaluation is completed on May 17, likely will be significant in determining what happens next with the youth.

Copyright 2015 The Billings Gazette. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

(9) Comments

  1. billmillerjr
    Report Abuse
    billmillerjr - May 12, 2013 7:39 pm
    dont coddle criminals who know right from wrong--jail them
  2. lefty the cowboy
    Report Abuse
    lefty the cowboy - May 12, 2013 10:40 am
    My apologies... me or my computer might have mistakenly posted a general comment as a reply to your own. I would point out this case might be something other than as reported...
  3. lefty the cowboy
    Report Abuse
    lefty the cowboy - May 12, 2013 10:38 am
    The locals, and this nitwit judge, say this kid has problems, but sometimes they are the ones with the 'problem'. I am thoroughly familar with a case in which a rural Montana school, the School District and the Sheriffs Office all insisted a kid who never did anything more wrong than 'normal' kids was a menace and shouldn't be allowed to associate with 'normal' people. In that case 'normal' meant white. The boy was eventually awarded separate judgements before separate Judges (both Fed and State) against the School District and the county, for discrimination... but only after his parents spent a fortune on medical opinions and lawyers, and the kid had endured an entire school career of abuse. btw, he was, and still is, very popular with his classmates, and he gets the last laugh, being one of the more successful members of his graduating class.

  4. lefty the cowboy
    Report Abuse
    lefty the cowboy - May 12, 2013 10:34 am
    The locals, and this nitwit judge, say this kid has problems, but sometimes they are the ones with the 'problem'. I am thoroughly familar with a case in which a rural Montana school, the School District and the Sheriffs Office all insisted a kid who never did anything more wrong than 'normal' kids was a menace and shouldn't be allowed to associate with 'normal' people. In that case 'normal' meant white. The boy was eventually awarded separate judgements before separate Judges (both Fed and State) against the School District and the county, for discrimination... but only after his parents spent a fortune on medical opinions and lawyers, and the kid had endured an entire school career of abuse. btw, he was, and still is, very popular with his classmates, and he gets the last laugh, being one of the more successful members of his graduating class.
  5. Lifesgood
    Report Abuse
    Lifesgood - May 12, 2013 8:55 am
    Wow they can use that kinda of strictness everywhere! Along with there parents who raise them.
  6. cutypye
    Report Abuse
    cutypye - May 12, 2013 7:20 am
    What part of he needs some kind of help does she not see?
    This story was in the national news,so everyone knows he has trouble.
    He ,knew what the limits and terms were.Yet He ,choose to violate them.
    And,alot of people come from broken homes.That is not a free pass to get away with something.IF ,they can offer some kind of help he is not getting at home?Then by all means let him get that help.Now,while he is still young...avoiding the problem will not make it go away.
  7. Jack
    Report Abuse
    Jack - May 11, 2013 2:30 pm
    Gramma should have thought about the consequences of her own failure to ignore the orders of the court several times and not take the boy to his appointments that he clearly needed . Obviously the young boy needs some help and the adults in his life are failing him and passing him off to someone else when the going gets tough. I hope this young man gets the help he needes before its too late!
  8. TheOriginalOutlaw
    Report Abuse
    TheOriginalOutlaw - May 11, 2013 11:54 am
    Where is that Willie Wonka egg tester when you need it?
  9. ruby
    Report Abuse
    ruby - May 11, 2013 10:40 am
    This family is in clear denial!!! Who would in their right mind would rather a little boy be bounced from home to home including foster homes than to get him the help he so very clearly needs? Negligent much there Granny!?!?

    I guess it starts with the parents who gave him the boots when they split. This little guy and his situation makes my heart hurt. Poor fella :( Somebody has to look out for him!!

Comment policy

We provide this forum for readers to exchange ideas and opinions on the day's news. Passionate views, pointed criticism and critical thinking are welcome. Name-calling, crude language and abuse are not. You must be logged into a personal account on Facebook to comment (FAQ). Readers are responsible for their comments and abuse of this privilege will not be tolerated. We reserve the right, without warning or notification, to remove comments and block users we determine violate our Terms of Service. Comments reflect the opinions of the author - not those of The Billings Gazette or its parent company.

Add Comment
You must Login to comment.

Click here to get an account it's free and quick

More from the Gazette

Poplar woman killed in rollover crash

13 hours ago(0)
N.D. truck driver sentenced on sex trafficking, child porn charges

N.D. truck driver sentenced on sex trafficking, child porn charges

14 hours ago(0)
Missoula's Greenough Mansion inspired young Paul Harvey

Missoula's Greenough Mansion inspired young Paul Harvey

15 hours ago(0)

Beartooth Pass opens for season

18 hours ago(0)
Regent questions renaming UM law school without public input

Regent questions renaming UM law school without public input

May 21, 2015 10:15 pm(1)

‘Pretty monumental’ event center construction begins in Watford City

May 21, 2015 8:00 pm(0)

Landowners protest proposed Bakken pipeline in Iowa

May 21, 2015 7:00 pm(0)
Man's fight to undo rape conviction sparks debate at Supreme Court

Man's fight to undo rape conviction sparks debate at Supreme Court

May 21, 2015 7:00 pm(0)

Follow The Billings Gazette

Popular Stories

Get weekly ads via e-mail

Deals & Offers

Featured Businesses