The 2012 Election

Outside money in Senate race may top $30 million

Rehberg, Tester campaigns have poured $18 million more into the contest
2012-11-04T00:10:00Z 2012-11-04T17:44:04Z Outside money in Senate race may top $30 millionBy MIKE DENNISON Gazette State Bureau The Billings Gazette
November 04, 2012 12:10 am  • 

HELENA — If you’re a Montana voter, on Tuesday you’ll have just finished a perverse sort of media marathon, navigating more than 100,000 TV ad spots and thousands of mailers, newspaper ads, phone calls, polls and canvassers, costing close to $50 million.

And that’s for only one race: The U.S. Senate, which has seen political groups pour money into Montana like never before, to persuade voters to choose Democratic U.S. Sen. Jon Tester, Republican challenger Rep. Denny Rehberg or Libertarian Dan Cox.

The candidates have spent about $18 million on this race, on broadcast ads, mailers, signs, fundraising events and their campaign staff.

But even bigger this year is the torrent of so-called “outside money,” spent primarily by interest groups with names like Crossroads GPS, Americans for Prosperity, Citizens for Strength and Security or Workers Voice.

This money can be difficult to track, but a variety of sources indicate it is approaching $30 million in Montana’s U.S. Senate race.

Everyone knew the Montana Senate contest would attract big money, because it’s a possible swing seat, where Republicans could pick up a seat by knocking off an incumbent Democrat.

Rehberg, a sitting congressman, was a viable challenger to Tester from the beginning, and he has run a disciplined, well-financed campaign.

“Rehberg wouldn’t have all this dough (on his side) if he weren’t already in the U.S. House,” Craig Wilson, a political science professor at Montana State University Billings. “That’s attracted millions of dollars.”

Yet it appears the amount of outside money is surpassing earlier expectations.

“I think 2010 was kind of a test case for a lot of these groups, and now they’ve rolled out the carpet big time,” said David Parker, a Montana State University political scientist following the race. “This could be the new normal.”

Tester has been the beneficiary of plenty of outside cash, and his campaign has outspent Rehberg’s by $10.7 million to $7.2 million as of two weeks ago.

But it appears the outside money has favored Rehberg, by about $16.5 million to $12.5 million, based on conversations with the campaigns and academics tracking the outside cash.

In all, at least 26 political party and interest groups have bought ads, paid for mailers and made other expenditures in Montana on behalf of Tester, Rehberg or, in some cases, Cox.

The Wesleyan Media Project, an academic group tracking TV campaign ads nationwide, said 89,000 separate TV ads on Montana’s Senate race appeared from June through late October — more than any other Senate race in the country.

One of the biggest spenders on the race has been Crossroads GPS, founded by Karl Rove, strategist and top staffer for former President George W. Bush. Crossroads has been running TV ads attacking Tester for most of the summer and fall.

The U.S. Chamber of Commerce and the National Republican Senatorial Committee also have bought many ads going after Tester.

On the other side, big spenders include the League of Conservation Voters, Patriot Majority, Montana Hunters & Anglers Action and Workers Voice, a labor group.

They’re not buying only TV ads, either. Some are spending money on mailers or hiring canvassers to identify specific, sympathetic voters and get them to the polls on Election Day.

“The mailers are better able to target specific voters, whereas TV ads are broad brush strokes,” Parker said. “The ads create the strategic playing field upon which the game is played, but the mailers, the get-out-the-vote are tactical decisions to convince one individual voter to vote.”

Much of this cash is being spent in Montana by what’s known as “dark money” groups, which do not have to report their donors.

Organized as nonprofits, they run ads attacking a candidate but don’t expressly ask voters to vote for or against the candidate. This distinction allows groups to call themselves “social welfare” organizations that are merely “educating” the public about candidates.

Such groups don’t have to reveal their donors and must report campaign-related spending made only within 60 days of the election.

Parker and the Sunlight Foundation, a group that tracks outside spending, estimate that about $14 million in “dark money” has been spent on the Montana U.S. Senate race. The remainder of outside spending has come from political party groups and other groups with stiffer requirements for reporting.

Tester’s campaign manager, Preston Elliott, said the huge level of outside spending in Montana’s race “is directly related to the Citizens United decision, which Jon Tester has been fighting against.”

“Like most Montanans, Jon believes we need more accountability — not more money — in our elections," Elliott said.

Citizens United is the 2010 decision by the U.S. Supreme Court that said corporations and unions can spend directly from their treasury on advertising to promote or oppose a candidate.

Citizens United didn’t change the rules for “dark money” nonprofit groups, which could accept corporate money before the decision and not report its source.

However, most experts on campaign-finance issues believe Citizens United may have emboldened the nonprofit groups and their use of corporate money, because it removed any chance that they could be penalized for using corporate funds to influence an election.

“I think some of this behavior was here before (Citizens United),” Parker said. “But Citizens United (and other court decisions) have allowed people to engage in bad behavior and vandalize the public square with their bad behavior. The attacks from outside groups are harsher.”

Rehberg campaign spokesman Chris Bond said there’s obviously been a lot of outside money flowing into the race, and that it’s “because of the national importance of this election when it comes to the path that we take as a country: The Romney-Rehberg path or the Obama-Tester path.”

Copyright 2015 The Billings Gazette. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

More from the Gazette

Cold-weather birding often a hot pursuit

Cold-weather birding often a hot pursuit

3 hours agoLoading…
ND oil workers see hours cut as oil prices slump

ND oil workers see hours cut as oil prices slump

5 hours ago Photos


Downtown Missoula rampage preceded head-on crash

Downtown Missoula rampage preceded head-on crash

12 hours agoLoading…
Oil spill near Glendive latest in string of Casper company's pipeline breaks

Oil spill near Glendive latest in string of Casper company's pipeline breaks

16 hours ago Photos


Just chill: Your guide to ice fishing

Just chill: Your guide to ice fishing

17 hours agoLoading…

Hardin man charged with assault, child abuse

January 30, 2015 2:42 pmLoading…

Lame Deer man accused of sexual abuse

January 30, 2015 2:31 pmLoading…

Woman denies assault charges

January 30, 2015 2:24 pmLoading…

ATM taken from Polson bank

January 30, 2015 1:32 pmLoading…
Senate panel tables bill adding gay protections to law

Senate panel tables bill adding gay protections to law

January 30, 2015 1:20 pmLoading…

Cattle truck overturns near Jamestown; no animals killed

January 30, 2015 11:41 amLoading…

Follow The Billings Gazette

Popular Stories

Get weekly ads via e-mail

Deals & Offers

Featured Businesses