Prosecutors object to moving trial for killing of German teen

2014-08-13T07:20:00Z 2014-11-17T15:12:05Z Prosecutors object to moving trial for killing of German teenBy KATHRYN HAAKE Missoulian The Billings Gazette
August 13, 2014 7:20 am  • 

MISSOULA — Missoula County prosecutors are objecting to a change of venue request for the trial of Markus Kaarma, the 29-year-old Missoula man who shot and killed an unarmed German exchange student when the teen entered his Grant Creek garage on April 27.

In their motion to move the trial, Kaarma’s attorneys failed to prove that Missoula County’s jury pool has been tainted by media reports, argued Missoula Deputy County Attorney Jennifer Clark. There is no proof of actual prejudice in the community, she said, despite the defense’s argument that local media sensationalized the case and influenced community opinions.

“It is of paramount importance to note that the media coverage on this case has been factual in nature and does not contain editorializing or inflammatory language,” Clark contended in her objection.

In a motion to move the trial, Katie Lacny, one of Kaarma’s five attorneys, argued that both television and print media painted Kaarma as a “cold-blooded killer” in an attempt to vilify her client.

She described a “media frenzy” surrounding the case, as local media broadcast or published 188 items about the shooting. Of those 188 documents, 69 documents and photos related to the case were published in the Missoulian, but only 23 were actual articles. The remaining 46 items were photos and court documents. Included in her argument are pages upon pages of reader comments posted online at Missoulian.com.

However, those comments are not representative of the entire population of Missoula County, Clark argued, but rather are opinions voiced by a few of Missoulian.com readers, some of whom commented dozens of times.

“It must be emphasized that none of those comments appear in the print edition, television coverage of this case, or in the actual news story itself on the website, but rather are part of a comment section reached by a link from the news story itself,” Clark argued in her response.

As an example, attached to one Missoulian.com article about the case a single user commented 31 times and another user posted 34 times, Clark retorted.

“The Defendant cannot establish the need for a change of venue by showing that a few readers of the Missoulian, readers who may not even reside in Missoula County, have negative opinions of him,” she wrote.

Along with Lacny’s motion to move the trial venue, attorneys also filed a motion to keep Kaarma’s “bad acts” from the public by sealing the case’s pretrial proceedings. Missoula prosecutors didn’t object to that motion.

Kaarma’s attorneys will likely file a response to the prosecution’s motion before District Judge Ed McLean issues an order.

Kaarma’s attorneys contend that he shot Big Sky student Diren Dede in self-defense after his home was burglarized in the weeks prior to the April 27 incident.

But prosecutors paint a more sinister picture, arguing that Kaarma and his common-law wife, Janelle Pflager, premeditated the act by leaving the garage to their Grant Creek home partially open, setting a purse inside the garage, and setting up video surveillance and motion detectors.

When Dede entered the garage shortly after midnight, the couple was alerted to his presence by a video monitor. Kaarma grabbed his gun, exited the front door of the home and fired four times into the garage without turning on the light.

Two of the shots struck and killed Dede, who was apparently searching for alcohol in the garage.

Prosecutors later charged Tristan Staber, 18, and another teenager who is a minor, with burglarizing Kaarma’s home on at least one prior occasion. Neither alleged burglar had any connection to Dede.

Copyright 2015 The Billings Gazette. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

More from the Gazette

Legitimate questions and politics collide with welfare whistleblowers

Legitimate questions and politics collide with welfare whistleblowers

5 hours ago Photos

Photos

Loading…
Taxing and spending: How much money is coming in and how will it be spent

Taxing and spending: How much money is coming in and how will it be spent

16 hours ago Photos

Photos

Loading…
Helena man sentenced to 50 years for 11th drunk-driving offense

Helena man sentenced to 50 years for 11th drunk-driving offense

January 24, 2015 11:00 amLoading…
Missoula native Darian Stevens seeking X Games medal

Missoula native Darian Stevens seeking X Games medal

January 24, 2015 10:30 amLoading…
Carroll Saints help woman, child from burning car

Carroll Saints help woman, child from burning car

January 24, 2015 10:19 amLoading…
UM economists: Tourism powers economy, gas prices a concern in Bakken

UM economists: Tourism powers economy, gas prices a concern in Bakken

January 24, 2015 10:00 amLoading…
Man convicted in North Dakota oil patch murder appealing

Man convicted in North Dakota oil patch murder appealing

January 24, 2015 9:33 amLoading…

House committee advances income tax cut bills

January 23, 2015 6:15 pmLoading…
Plan would help small business pay for health insurance

Plan would help small business pay for health insurance

January 23, 2015 3:38 pmLoading…
Supporters rally as lawmakers weigh preschool plan

Supporters rally as lawmakers weigh preschool plan

January 23, 2015 1:23 pm Photos

Photos

Loading…
Lawmaker seeks to up penalty for abuse of pregnant women

Lawmaker seeks to up penalty for abuse of pregnant women

January 23, 2015 12:35 pmLoading…

Whitefish man pleads no contest to felony arson

January 23, 2015 11:41 amLoading…
Browning man accused of killing 3 grizzlies must pay $30K

Browning man accused of killing 3 grizzlies must pay $30K

January 23, 2015 11:16 amLoading…

Follow The Billings Gazette

Popular Stories

Get weekly ads via e-mail

Deals & Offers

Featured Businesses