Study: Wyoming wolves getting bad rap for elk decline

2013-06-11T06:00:00Z Study: Wyoming wolves getting bad rap for elk declineBy CHRISTINE PETERSON Casper Star-Tribune The Billings Gazette

Stress from wolves may not be the reason behind a declining elk population near Cody, according to a study published today. The conclusion stands in contrast to previous research, which held that increased stress from wolves was behind a drop in the number of elk in the Yellowstone area.

The presence of wolves doesn’t dramatically change the way elk behave, said Arthur Middleton, lead author of the paper published in the journal “Ecology Letters.” Earlier research suggested the mere presence of wolves stressed or scared elk so much that they moved large distances, hid in trees, and then became so unhealthy they lost pregnancies or simply couldn’t get pregnant.

Migratory elk in the Clark’s Fork Herd near Cody moved slightly when wolves came nearby, but not enough to change their eating habits, make them lose weight or prevent them from becoming pregnant, Middleton said.

Extensive look

The paper, “Linking anti-predator behaviour to prey demography reveals limited risk effects of an actively hunting large carnivore,” is one of three published by Middleton following an extensive study completed while working in the Wyoming Cooperative Fish and Wildlife Research Unit at the University of Wyoming. The study was backed by more than a dozen government and nonprofit organizations including the Wyoming Game and Fish Department, Wyoming Animal Damage Management Board, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Boone and Crockett Club and Safari Club International.

Middleton’s second paper from the study, published in the journal “Ecology,” found that drought and calf predation by grizzly bears were key factors behind the declining elk calf numbers. Wolves do eat adult elk, Middleton found, but not enough to significantly reduce elk numbers in the Clark’s Fork Herd.

“It’s fascinating to fund the research and let the chips fall where they may,” said Tom Toman, director of science and planning for the Rocky Mountain Elk Foundation, a leading sportsman organization, which helped fund the study.

“I am glad we have an objective look. It’s better to know exactly what’s going on other than anecdotes.”

Drops in elk calf ratios

Middleton started the study because migratory elk in the Clark’s Fork Herd saw drops in elk calf ratios starting in the mid-1990s and have remained low since 2002.

The migratory herd also had far fewer pregnancies than the elk in the herd that stayed near Cody year-round. Pregnancy rates for migratory and residential elk herds were historically equal.

Middleton and other biologists put GPS collars on both elk and wolves to observe the animals’ interactions. They spent more than three months each winter for three years monitoring the animals’ behavior.

They found wolves encounter elk relatively infrequently, and when they do, elk don’t respond dramatically, said Middleton, who is now at the Yale School of Forestry and Environmental Studies.

About 100 migratory elk moved through the Sunlight Basin area for every one wolf during the study. Ultimately, elk encountered a wolf on average every nine days. When they did interact, elk only seemed to react when wolves came within about half a mile. Elk increased their movement on average about 30 yards per hour in response.

It would be as though a bully sits down next to you in the lunchroom and you move to the next seat or the next table but continue eating. You don’t jog to the next town or hide, Middleton said.

The body fat of elk that interacted with wolves the most was the same as elk who had few wolf interactions, Middleton found.

People have likely seen wolves dramatically scatter herds of elk, but taken as a whole, wolf presence doesn’t have a significant impact on elk health, he said.

The results confirm what Cody Game and Fish biologist Douglas McWhirter believed. Elk, even in areas with high numbers of wolves, haven’t shifted to new areas, he said. Wildlife managers have cut back significantly on hunting licenses, and while calf survival is low, adult elk survival has been high.

If wolves’ presence doesn’t shift elk to new territory or prevent them from getting pregnant, then they also may not be the cause of the increase in willows and aspen in the Yellowstone area, as previously believed, he said.

“Even if wolves play a role it’s likely considerably smaller than we thought,” Middleton said.

Willows and aspen have improved, which is likely because all large carnivore numbers have increased in northwest Wyoming, especially Yellowstone National Park, resulting in an overall decrease in elk numbers, said Doug Smith, senior wildlife biologist with Yellowstone National Park.

Wolves and mountain lions eat elk and bears feed on elk calves. Fewer elk means fewer mouths to feed, which means more vegetative growth, Smith said.

People tend to blame wolves for everything, such as scaring elk into not becoming pregnant, or give them credit for everything, such as improving the greater Yellowstone ecosystem, said Mike Jimenez, wolf management and science coordinator for the Fish and Wildlife Service.

“Wolves are not that bad and not that good, they’re another part of wildlife,” Jimenez said. “As research goes on, that’s the part that’s so helpful. Wolves take their place like other predators or other parts of the ecosystem.”

Copyright 2015 The Billings Gazette. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

More from the Gazette

Religious freedom bill advances in Wyoming House

8 hours agoLoading…

University of Wyoming gets closer to finding permanent deans

8 hours agoLoading…

Tribal liaison overhaul receives initial approval in Senate

9 hours agoLoading…

Appropriations committee skeptical of 'squishy' Medicaid numbers

9 hours agoLoading…

BLM resource advisory council to meet

16 hours agoLoading…
Wyoming volunteers conduct annual homeless population census

Wyoming volunteers conduct annual homeless population census

16 hours agoLoading…

Mental health agencies worry about loss of funds

20 hours agoLoading…
Wyoming sportsmen oppose land transfer study bill

Wyoming sportsmen oppose land transfer study bill

January 28, 2015 5:30 pmLoading…
Liz Byrd, first black woman in Legislature, dies at 88

Liz Byrd, first black woman in Legislature, dies at 88

January 28, 2015 5:15 pmLoading…
Proposed Medicaid compromise relies on virtual money, incentives to save

Proposed Medicaid compromise relies on virtual money, incentives to save

January 28, 2015 5:00 pmLoading…

Drug and assault charges result in 160-day sentence

January 28, 2015 10:01 amLoading…
Cheyenne airport may lose $850,000 in federal funding

Cheyenne airport may lose $850,000 in federal funding

January 28, 2015 9:40 amLoading…

Follow The Billings Gazette

Popular Stories

Get weekly ads via e-mail

Deals & Offers

Featured Businesses