Skip to main content
You have permission to edit this article.
Book review: Early buzz on ‘The Other Black Girl’ is well-deserved

Book review: Early buzz on ‘The Other Black Girl’ is well-deserved

"The Other Black Girl" by Zakiya Dalila Harris.

"The Other Black Girl" by Zakiya Dalila Harris. (Simon & Schuster/TNS)

"The Other Black Girl" by Zakiya Dalila Harris; Atria (368 pages, $27)


Nella Rogers is the only Black woman at the all-white, very unwoke Wagner Books in Zakiya Dalila Harris’ stunning debut, “The Other Black Girl,” an insightful, often uncomfortable, look at race, office politics, jealousy, ambition and friendship.

Nella both revels in and reviles her status at the Manhattan publisher. She’s often asked to weigh in on “Black issues,” but then her opinion is ignored if it doesn’t fit her white bosses’ opinions. Her involvement with the publisher’s “Diversity Town Halls” often is belittled as is the program that does little. Then there are the little slights — the name is Nella, not Nelly — and the bigger snubs, like the mediocre job performance reviews designed to keep this overworked editorial assistant from being promoted.

Then, sophisticated, confident Hazel-May McCall becomes “The Other Black Girl” to join Wagner. Nella and Hazel-May seem to instantly click, conferring about office politics and personalities and how to maneuver the details of publishing. Those thoughtless acts of disrespect continue — more than once Nella is mistaken for Hazel-May.

Nella is astounded at the fearlessness that seems to come naturally from Hazel-May, who doesn’t hesitate to share her unfiltered thoughts. Now Nella’s opinions are taken even less seriously, as Hazel-May’s status quickly rises. More editors, including Nella’s immediate supervisor, seek out Hazel-May.

Taking a cue from Hazel-May, Nella volunteers her unvarnished thoughts on a popular, best-selling author’s insensitive portrayal of a Black single mom. It doesn’t go well. Soon the dynamics switch as Nella wonders if Hazel-May truly is a friend and ally. Then Nella begins receiving anonymous, vaguely threatening notes that keep escalating in tone, telling her to leave Wagner.

“The Other Black Girl” is strongest in its penetrating look at book publishing, augmented by snappy, often witty dialogue, sharply created characters and well-placed pop culture references. The hilarious — and realistic — scene in which Nella firmly but diplomatically confronts the white author’s stereotypical depiction of a young Black woman is unforgettable, as is his undiplomatic reaction.

Plot allusions to “Stepford Wives,” “All About Eve” and “Get Out” work well. However, the suspense/mystery aspects of “The Other Black Girl” are often confusing and feel like an afterthought.

Still, this doesn’t detract from Harris’ intelligent story and smart turn of phrase, and a stunning ending. Anyone who has felt alienated at work and feared for their job can relate to Nella, regardless of race. “Lurking beneath many of the friendly seeming meetings was an environment of pettiness and power plays; cold shoulders and closed-door conversations.”

White readers may be a bit uneasy as Harris precisely shows those bits of racism that are easy to dismiss. “The Other Black Girl” may succeed in making readers be more thoughtful in how they interact with others.

Early buzz has named “The Other Black Girl” one of the summer’s most anticipated novels. (Another being S.A. Cosby’s “Razorblade Tears.”) The buzz is correct.


Stay up-to-date on what's happening

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Most Popular

Sure, Prince William’s tweets made international news after the Euro 2020 soccer championships. But his brother, Harry, is on a mission to craft his own narrative, one far longer than 280 characters. Backed by Penguin Random House, the younger prince will publish an “intimate and heartfelt” memoir on the life, lessons and losses that have shaped him, tentatively planned for release in late ...

It's been only a few months since I took on the monumental task of organizing my books, and once again, they are a mess. Last September, I went through every book in the house and decided on what to keep and what to give. The "to give" pile turned into dozens of piles, bags and boxes, filling our front porch. I hauled tables out into the front yard, invited friends and neighbors to stop by, ...

The Barack Obama and Bruce Springsteen brotherhood of man mission continues. “Renegades,” the podcast collaboration between the former president and the Boss has been repurposed and will be released as a book this fall. “Renegades: Born in the USA,” the book adaptation, will be released Oct. 26, Penguin Random House announced on Thursday. The 320-page tome will retail for $50 and include ...

FICTION: A migrant child washes up on a beach — alive — in Omar El Akkad's follow-up to "American War." "What Strange Paradise" by: Omar El Akkad; Alfred A. Knopf (256 pages, $25.95) ——— In his 2017 debut novel, "American War," Omar El Akkad spotlighted Middle East humanitarian crises by reimagining them on U.S. soil. Perhaps, the novel implied, Americans might pay refugees and sectarian ...

Here are the bestsellers for the week that ended Saturday, July 17, compiled from data from independent and chain bookstores, book wholesalers and independent distributors nationwide, powered by NPD BookScan © 2021 NPD Group. (Reprinted from Publishers Weekly, published by PWxyz LLC. © 2021, PWxyz LLC.) HARDCOVER FICTION 1. The Cellist. Daniel Silva. Harper 2. The Last Thing He Told Me. Laura ...

"Rachel to the Rescue" by Elinor Lipman; Mariner Press (296 pages, $15.99) ——— Elinor Lipman's latest novel, "Rachel to the Rescue," might not stand the test of time, but for this particular time, it's hilarious. Rachel has just gotten fired from her job in the Trump White House for accidentally sending an email to the entire White House staff criticizing the president. (Oh, the perils of ...

NONFICTION: Liv Arnesen recounts her 1994 solo journey to the South Pole. "Skiing Into the Bright Open" by Liv Arnesen, translated from the Norwegian by Roland Huntford; University of Minnesota Press (208 pages, $21.95) ——— There's something wonderfully perplexing about Norwegian adventurer Liv Arnesen's account of her solo ski journey to the South Pole. She did this in 1994, the first woman ...

FICTION: A thrilling debut in which a pilot must crash his plane to save his family. "Falling" by T.J. Newman; Avid Reader Press (304 pages, $28) ——— Early into "Falling," and not long into a flight from Los Angeles to New York, the pilot-protagonist Bill Hoffman takes a calculated risk and confides in a hushed tone to his friend. "Jo," he whispers. "We have a situation." Which is something of ...

In Maggie Nelson’s “Bluets,” her 2009 collection of poems on grief and loss, loneliness is “solitude with a problem.” Which is a useful way of understanding loneliness. Being alone and feeling lonely are not always the same thing. Except, of course, it’s complicated. Emily Dickinson wondered: Was loneliness “the maker of the soul”? Or its “seal”? Does loneliness define you? Or exacerbate ...

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Breaking News