Skip to main contentSkip to main content
You have permission to edit this article.
Review: 'We Are Meant to Rise,' edited by Carolyn Holbrook and David Mura

Review: 'We Are Meant to Rise,' edited by Carolyn Holbrook and David Mura

  • 0
"We Are Meant to Rise," edited by Carolyn Holbrook and David Mura.

"We Are Meant to Rise," edited by Carolyn Holbrook and David Mura. (University of Minnesota Press/TNS)

A collection of essays from a wide-ranging group of Minnesota writers exploring life during COVID-19 and the aftermath of the murder of George Floyd.

"We Are Meant to Rise," edited by Carolyn Holbrook and David Mura; University of Minnesota Press (224 pages, $18.95)


Who is allowed to tell their story? Who is silenced? And what is lost when stories go untold? As the anthology "We Are Meant to Rise" shows, the impact of untold stories not only constricts the lives of those unheard, but it also allows others to assume that one person's story can represent entire communities.

The More Than A Single Story organization was founded in 2015 by Minnesota writer Carolyn Holbrook as a means to amplify the voices of Minnesota writers of color and Indigenous writers. Its aim is also to combat the stereotypes that emerge when one person's story is seen as "representative" of an entire community.

Holbrook says that the idea for her project came about when a white woman at a public reading was surprised that the varied members of a panel did not share the same viewpoint. It was a shocking moment but it inspired Holbrook to create a forum where polyphonic voices could be heard.

Now Holbrook and David Mura have gathered together nearly three dozen essays and poems that testify to the experiences of storytellers from across the region.

The pieces were written in the past two years, and not surprisingly, COVID-19 casts its shadow on many of the stories, the details of how the daily restrictions that controlling the pandemic necessitated were felt in the BIPOC community. But it is impossible to write about life in Minnesota in 2020 without confronting the murder of George Floyd, how it galvanized protesters, but also how its vibrations echoed in the lives of those who had experienced the insidious ways that prejudice cramps a life.

"We Are Meant to Rise" is a triumph of story-telling, a panoply of experiences drawn from the diverse peoples of Minnesota. But it also raises the fundamental questions that all of us confront as Americans. As Mura writes in his introduction, "Out of so many different voices, out of such diversity, how do we come together to create a society that is truly democratic and truly just, that provides a space and opportunity for all of us to thrive?"

One of my favorite pieces is by Ed Bok Lee, an essay written in list form that probes gently at the edges of isolation, asking how the need to protect the body from contagion cuts us off from the necessary things that sustain a life. "Whatever makes us smile, hug, kiss, share food with beloved strangers, invent songs and sometimes even belly-aching jokes of death, is also contagious. In fact, everything but the physical body dies without this."

Mona Susan Power's memoir of the rich legacy she inherited from her Ihanktunwanna Sioux family, including her mother's admonitions to never admit weakness, is powerfully explored. But as she writes in heartbreaking detail, the complicated legacy of inheriting a survivor's strength prevents her from asking for help for a long time, until she reaches crisis. Her breakdown allows her to heal stronger at the broken places, a way to heal the trauma that has been passed down through generations.

Empathy for others is one way to break down the artificial barriers we construct. But getting to empathy and understanding requires that no single story be taken as the only voice that matters. While the common theme that runs through the pieces is a sort of "how we have lived through the past two years," the range of responses feels like a broadening of the world after so many months of contraction.


Lorraine Berry is a writer and critic in Oregon.


Stay up-to-date on what's happening

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Most Popular

“Shackleton: The Biography” by Ranulph Fiennes; Pegasus Books (452 pages, $32) ——— Sometimes the greatest victories are hidden in defeats. Sir Ernest Shackleton wanted to be the first man to reach the South Pole, the first to cross Antarctica. He failed at both. Yet he became a hero anyway and is famous for his explorations. Ranulph Fiennes’ “Shackleton: The Biography” explains why. Part of an ...

FICTION: A couple's twin memoirs generate more heat than light. "A Previous Life" by Edmund White; Bloomsbury (288 pages, $26) ——— He's handsome, wealthy, athletic, highly intelligent (as he reminds us frequently), multilingual, sexually irresistible, musically gifted. Ruggero, the bisexual Sicilian harpsichordist at the center of "A Previous Life," the newest novel by Edmund White, is also, ...

Still January? Check. Still pandemic? Check. Need a new book? Check, check, check. Visit a local indie bookstore — they're probably having a post-holiday slump too — and pick up a new paperback; maybe one of these brand-new ones. "The Swallowed Man" by Edward Carey (Penguin, $17). Author and visual artist Carey ("Little") in this novel takes on the tale of Pinocchio, but from a decidedly ...

It’s a shame that you don’t know Gary Paulsen, that his name was never as recognizable as a Beverly Cleary (“Ramona the Pest”) or an Eric Carle (“The Very Hungry Caterpillar”), all of whom wrote books for children and all of whom died last year. At least, I’m assuming you’ve never heard of Gary Paulsen. It’s a big assumption. His books sold more than 35 million copies, and if you came of age ...

If you're planning to read a book, who cares how long it takes to read it? Who's keeping score? Raise your hand if you've said these words: "I want to read that book, but it's too long!" I've said this myself, even though it reflects a sentiment that makes no sense, when you think about it. If you're planning to read a book, who cares how long it takes to read it? Who cares if you spend six ...

One Black academic's exploration of the South seeks to center the region as the "soul of America." "South to America" by Imani Perry; Ecco (432 pages, $28.99) ——— "Every other region can jam its fingers in its ears and shake its head and tunelessly chant, 'Not in my backyard,' but not so the South," ZZ Packer observes in her introduction to the 2008 edition of "New Stories From the South." ...

Intricately enmeshed stories examine personal ties between families in China and the United States over the past 50 years. "Thank You, Mr. Nixon" by Gish Jen; Alfred A. Knopf (272 pages, $28) (In bookstores Feb. 1.) ——— "Thank You, Mr. Nixon," Gish Jen's first collection of short fiction in more than 20 years, is a jewel box of creativity and a joy to uncover. Across 11 synergistic stories ...

MINNEAPOLIS — In 2007, after the death of his grandfather, Sequoia Nagamatsu flew off to Japan, where he had never been, to teach English and to grieve. It was there that he started writing. "My grandfather's death had a profound impact on me," Nagamatsu said in a recent interview from his home in Minneapolis. "I wasn't really able to say goodbye." In Japan, he was surrounded by reminders of ...

CHICAGO — I’ve been reading about Lorraine Hansberry. After a long time of not reading very much at all about Lorraine Hansberry. There just wasn’t that much out there about her to read. Her work is (still) not in the Library of America, and even her papers were not generally available to scholars until a couple of decades ago. So there were few major biographies or revelations. Until about ...

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Breaking News