Skip to main content
You have permission to edit this article.
Guest opinion: Custer's crucial battle at Gettysburg 150 years ago

Guest opinion: Custer's crucial battle at Gettysburg 150 years ago

Pickett's Charge

This artist’s rendering shows Gen. George Pickett’s Confederate infantrymen charging Union soldiers in a desperate attempt to break the Union line on Cemetery Ridge during the battle of Gettysburg on July 3, 1863. The attack failed. The South suffered terrible losses. It was the climactic struggle of the three-day battle.

The name George Custer is etched in the annals of U.S. and Montana history for the Battle of the Little Bighorn in 1876. Less well known is that Custer may have been the man who won the Civil War. The incident, known mostly only to Civil War buffs, occurred at the critical climax of that war’s decisive battle, at Gettysburg, on July 3 — 150 years ago.

Under the gifted leadership of Gen. Robert E. Lee, the South had won a series of battles against attacking Union armies. The Confederates decided to become the attackers by invading the vital Northern state of Pennsylvania. A victory there could force the U.S. government to grant independence to the Confederate states.

Lee’s ragged army was able to live off the rich Pennsylvania countryside, until then unravaged by war. The Southerners, some of them barefoot, were probably primarily interested in the shoes thought to be manufactured in Gettysburg. On July 1 they shattered a smaller Union force, chasing them through Gettysburg where they dug in on a fishhook-shaped ridge a short distance beyond the town.

Encouraged by their easy victory, the confident Confederates attacked the next day in the spirit that ultimate victory was in their grasp, but the Northern defenders held their ground.

That night the fate of the Confederacy was on Lee’s shoulders. If he could win the battle, he could win the war. If not, his ill-equipped and outnumbered army might never have the chance again.

Pickett’s charge

He decided to send a force of about 15,000 men, including the fresh Virginia division of Gen. George Pickett, to attack the center of the Northern line. The men would have to charge across a mile of open field, all the time within deadly range of artillery backing up the defenders of the ridge, and much of the time within range of their rifles.

The bloody repulse of the charge is regarded as Lee’s greatest failure. He retreated on July 4, which ironically might have been Confederate Independence Day. Could the desperate charge have possibly succeeded? Defenders of Lee’s reputation think it could have if what they believe was Lee’s entire intricate plan had been executed as he planned it.

Lee sent his cavalry force, about 6,000 mounted men, around to the rear of the ridge. If they could attack from behind at the precise time of Pickett’s charge, unsuspecting Northern artillerymen attempting to “stick to their guns” would be easy prey for the horsemen’s sabers. Then, attacked from both sides, the Northern infantry line might have been broken.

The plan failed because a force of about 2,000 Northern cavalry, piecemealed together by the colorful “Boy General” George Custer, intercepted the superior force of the Southern cavalry, and fought them to a standstill. Unable to accomplish their mission in the narrow window of time, they withdrew, and facing the full, undistracted fury of the dug-in defenders, Pickett’s hapless attackers were annihilated.

Sheridan’s unique gift

With flowing curls and red cravat, the colorful Custer went on to other Civil War glories. In the end, he was uniquely rewarded with the war’s most significant trophy. Union Gen. Phillip Sheridan purchased the table on which Gen. Ulysses S. Grant wrote the surrender terms for Lee to sign, and presented it to Custer with a note to Custer’s wife. It said: “Permit me to say, madam, that there is scarcely an individual in our service who has contributed more to bring about this desirable result than your gallant husband.”

Bob Brown of Whitefish is a former Montana secretary of state and state Senate president.



Catch the latest in Opinion

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Breaking News